Sommie Santilla

UX + PRODUCT DESIGNER

Crafting with curiosity and compassion to make experiences connective and effortless.

UX/UI

Product Design

CLIENT WORK

CONTRACT

DESKTOP

Gamifying the game learning experience

Investigation of how gamification can address motivation and retention rates within game development on Unity Learn.

I was hands-on from the beginning research phase all throughout until our final design phase on a student-led team. I contributed largely by leading the wireframing, testing, and iteration phases through spearheading the processes and redesigning the Learning dashboard, transition from lesson-to-lesson/pathway, as well as the final summary pages.

Role

Product Designer

Prototyping Lead

Timeline

10 weeks

September - December 2024

team

1 PM

3 Designers

skills

User Research

Journey Mapping

UX/UI Design

Wireframing

Usability Testing

Company

Unity Learn is Unity's dedicated education platform where individuals are able to learn game development and design for free using the Unity engine.

tldr

Unity Learners are not completing the curriculum due to lack of motivation

Our team tasked to address the problem of retention through leveraging gamification and nudge elements without making changes to the curriculum itself.

PROBLEM STATEMENT

How might we better visualize, incentive, and reward our users' learning progress on Unity Learn, such that they will be motivated to continue?

Final solution

Goal-oriented progress (formerly "topic-specific progress")

Learners track progress toward their personal goals as they complete lessons, missions, and pathwaysโ€”so even content outside their specific interests still feel valuable, since it builds towards core skills in the field.

Visual indicators: streaks, progress bars and maps

Learners are driven by progress. Bringing forward what has already been accomplished helps students understand how far they have come. This anchors them to complete their current tutorial to reach the next goalpost.

Streamlining the "Next Steps"

Reducing friction by including moments of delight when reviewing of accomplishmentsโ€”reduces confusion on where to go after completion. Highlighting what has been completed as an option to review further boosts the validation that their learning contributed to a quantifiable metric.

Community leaderboard

Learners are motivated by other learners: whether for inspiration or for the competitive edge. Users can also choose to compete with themselves if the progress of others intimidates them.

Context

Retention requires motivation and incentives to return

Learning game design and development can take months and years to learn, which can be discouraging to many complete the curriculum.

6

Pathways to complete

~50 weeks

Estimated time to complete

750+ hours

Of Curriculum content

research

To understand where Unity Learn can grow, we conducted four methods of research for familiarity in game design and learning habits.

Preliminary Research

We engaged in academic research, competitive analysis, and evaluated Unity Learn through SWOT to understand the landscape.

User Interviews

Interviewed 8 developers of varying skill levels to identify what drives and blocks their learning process.

Surveys

We surveyed 65 game developers to quantify their learning preferences and experiences.

Diary Study

Tracked a learner over 8 weeks and 6 checkpoints to observe where friction appeared and users dropped off.

takeaways

Beginner vs Intermediate vs Advanced: Beginners require the greatest amount of support.

Beginners were the most vulnerable user group to target due to having the largest learning curve. This is where learners build habits, develop discipline in maintaining motivation, and encounter learning both Unity engine and the content skills.

Personas + Journey Maps

Feeling fatigued from experience.

Lack of smooth and intuitive transition from one mission to the next

โ€œMove on to next stepโ€ button does not work

Quizzes were overall very helpful

๐Ÿ˜

๐Ÿคฉ

๐Ÿ˜Œ

๐Ÿ˜ค

๐Ÿฅณ

โ˜บ๏ธ

๐Ÿ˜‘

Closes computer and shows work to friends

Must leave page, reload page, re-find Unity Learn

Users click on next task manually

Some basics were skipped over that would be helpful to learn


No issues with the new user registration process

Takes quiz after each mission is complete.


Complete the learning objectives of the pathway


Starts Unity essentials pathway

Goes on Unity Learnโ€™s sign up

No issues with finding a pathway to start

Goal

Aims to create mobile game for fun.

Pain Points

Has limited time commitments, struggles with debugging coding issues, and new to gaming community.

Key insights

Community

Learners need a support system through community for mentorship, connections, and advice.

Eyes on the Prize

Clear objectives drive passion and motivation: reminders of the goals they are working towards.

Bite-sized Digestibility & Visual Indicators

Users are empowered by small wins and discouraged by long lessons without clear indication of how far they have gone. The need structured paths and reminders of what they have accomplished to keep moving forward.

ideation

Translating our insights through 4-5-4 cluster ideation, we expanded on each idea pitched

We fleshed out concepts to address the three key takeaways for our solution by building off of the ideas by each designer.

8 preliminary ideas extracted -> 5 were finalized based on a values rubric and client feedback

Each designer evaluated ideas based on the following methods. Paired with the prioritization of our stakeholder, we focused on the solutions that best addressed our problem statement.

Visual Progress

โ€œNext Stepsโ€

Streaks

Community Leaderboard

Topic-specific progress

Feasibility

Engages Community

Streamlines Content

Incentivizes Learning

Clarifies Objective

Applies most

Applies least

usability testing

As prototyping sprint lead, I implemented testing within our early design phase in order to validate our solutions at a small scale.

Although limited, this allowed us to evaluate our solutions early on with learners, which was valuable in qualifying the new features we were pitching to our client. I particularly focused on designing on the "topic/goal-oriented progress", "streaks", and visuals for the "next steps."

Community Leaderboard, Beginner

Competitive learning can be important and can segway into a networking experience

Community Showcase, Beginner

Its a big inspiration to see similar projects that you have also made. This would really help me get involved.

Streaks, Beginner

โ€œI like the idea of the gradients to see how much you contributed and learned each day. I donโ€™t see a negative impactโ€

Next Steps, Beginner

โ€œI like the preview into the next partโ€

Next Steps, Beginner

Next Steps should be after each Mission rather than tutorials

Next Steps, Beginner

Being able to summarize everything you learned in a big piece for me, it helps me bring everything together

Next Steps, Beginner

โ€œModals can be frustrating for our usersโ€

Streaks, Beginner

Thereโ€™s nothing really I would change, its simple and easy to digest.

Goal-oriented progress, Beginner

โ€œI love the pathway progress! It feels encouraging to see where I amโ€

We conducted two rounds of usability testing, for our low fidelity and mid fidelity designs

finalized direction: adjustments

01

Next Steps: Modals vs Embedded onto the page

Client expressed that learners found too many popups a nuisance in their user flow, particularly for shorter lessons which prompt too many popups in a short amount of time.

02

Visual Progress Indicator

There is no indicator for the current mission/pathway that the user is in the middle of on the home dashboard. I added a skills summary page so that learners are able to review exactly what they have completed as motivation to keep moving forward to the next lesson.

03

Community Leaderboard

The initially proposed social media format is not feasible from a development perspective, according to our clients. Learners also expressed potential intimidated by leaderboard due to possibility of imposter syndrome. The addition of personal statistics allows users to select between community competitiveness or personal statistics.

impact

Tyler W, beginner

โ€œSeeing my results right in front of me is helpful for learning.โ€

Ben T, intermediate

โ€œThe community is the most important part... Upperclassmen helped pass down the knowledge and trickled down to underclassmen...Thereโ€™s so much niche knowledge to share about this softwareโ€

Granger a, expert

โ€œNo one inherently cares about a hat, but people care about rewards and having a feedback loopโ€

Reflection

Implementing Usability Testing within Timeline

01

Validating for our ideas

Despite the concerns about how it would play into our overall timeline, I proactively discussed the feasibility with our project mentor and worked with my teammates to devise a schedule that would allow us to have enough time to design and test. Although it was not a perfect condition to conduct usability testing, I was proud in the persistence and creative solutions that we were able to implement to have this form of testing.

FINAL WORDS

Thank you Neil & Kayla from Unity Learn SF!

The feedback and experience working with the Unity Learn team was amazing. As someone who has passion for designing in spaces for education and learning, I felt grateful for the opportunity to work on this project and receive valuable feedback from the Unity Learn team.

โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โฃ โฃคโฃคโฃ€โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €

โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โข€โฃพโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃทโ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €

โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โฃพโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโขฟโฃฟโฃทโ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €

โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ  โ  โฃ„โก€โ €โ €โขฟโกฟโขฟโกโฃฟโฃฟโขฟโข‹โ €โข€โฃ โฃคโฃถโฃฆโก€โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €

โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ ˜โก‹โข’โ šโ ฟโฃฟโฃทโ ฆโ œโขฟโฃฟโก…โขฝโก‡โ €โ €โฃผโกŸโข‰โขˆโฃผโ ฟโฃปโก„โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €

โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โฃ โฃดโฃถโฃถโฃฆโก€โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โขธโฃ„โ ‰โ ‚โฃธโฃฟโขฟโฃงโฃฌโ ›โกโก€โ ‰โ €โกพโ ‹โ คโ šโฃ‰โฃตโ ฟโ ƒโ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €

โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โฃผโฃทโฃฝโฃปโฃฟโฃฟโฃทโก€โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ ‰โ ณโ Œโก›โ ฟโฃฟโกฟโ ฟโ ดโกโก‡โ €โ €โ €โ †โฃ˜โฃ›โ ‹โ โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €

โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฎโฃŸโฃฟโกงโขคโฃคโฃ€โฃ€โฃคโ ”โฃถโฃฆโก€โ €โข€โฃ€โฃ€โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ ˆโฃ‰โฃโฃ โฃทโฃคโ €โขฐโฃพโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฆโก€โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €

โฃดโฃฆโฃคโฃ„โฃ€โก€โ €โขฟโฃถโฃฟโฃปโกผโฃพโฃฏโขทโขธโฃฎโกโฃฟโก„โ €โขธโฃโ €โขธโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃงโฃ€โ €โ €โ €โ €โข€โฃคโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโ ‡โ ˜โ ปโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโก†โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €

โฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโขฟโฃ‡โก€โ ปโฃฟโขปโฃทโกฟโฃปโฃทโฃฝโขฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃงโก€โขพโกโข€โฃผโขŸโ ฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโก‡โ €โ €โ €โ ‰โ ’โ ถโ ถโ ฌโกฟโ ‹โ €โฃ โฃดโฃพโฃฏโฃŸโ ›โ ‹โข‰โก™โ Ÿโ โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €

โขนโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฏโฃปโฃžโขทโ ™โ €โข™โ ƒโขฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฝโฃฏโฃฝโ ƒโขธโกทโ โ ‘โฃ‹โฃธโกฟโฃ›โ ฟโ โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โฃดโขƒโขถโ ›โ ƒโฃญโ ฒโฃพโฃโกฟโ ›โกถโ ฉโ โข›โฃณโฃถโฃฆโ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โฃ โฃฎโฃดโฃถโฃถโฃฆโ €โ €โ €โ €โ €

โ ˆโขปโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโ ถโฃ„โขขโ ˆโ €โ €โ ˜โ ฟโฃฏโฃนโฃทโ ปโ €โ €โ €โกดโ Ÿโข‹โฃโฃดโฃžโฃ€โฃ€โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โขธโฃŸโกธโ ‚โ €โ ณโกโ €โ €โ ˆโ กโขœโกณโขณโฃบโฃฟโฃญโขฟโฃพโฃงโ €โ €โ €โข€โกœโ ปโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโก‡โ €โ €โ €โ €

โ €โ €โฃ™โ ›โ ›โข›โฃ‹โฃกโฃคโฃฎโฃคโฃผโฃพโฃฟโฃฟโฃถโฃคโฃˆโ ฉโก„โ €โ €โ €โขโฃฒโฃปโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃทโ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ ˆโขโ ˜โขทโฃคโฃ…โ €โ €โ €โ ‚โ ปโฃฟโฃพโฃปโขฟโ ฟโฃฃโฃฌโก™โฃคโ €โ €โฃพโขโฃดโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโ ƒโ €โ €โ €โ €

โ €โ €โขธโฃคโฃ โฃ˜โฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฆโ โ €โ €โข€โฃธโฃ›โฃปโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโข€โก†โก€โ €โ €โฃคโ บโก”โ Šโก™โฃฟโก„โฃ€โฃ„โขถโฃคโฃญโ ปโ ฟโฃพโฃถโฃฟโฃฟโกงโขนโก†โ €โฃ‹โฃธโกฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโ ‚โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €

โ €โ €โ €โ ˆโ ™โ ›โ ›โขปโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฏโก›โขฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฏโฃถโฃฟโฃฟโฃฆโฃโกฝโขฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโกฟโ ฟโ ƒโกœโกœโก„โ €โขธโขขโ ณโฃŒโ ƒโขกโฃฟโก‡โขฟโกŒโฃงโฃปโกฐโฃ„โ ฐโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโ Ÿโฃกโฃฟโก‡โ ˜โขฟโฃฟโฃคโฃฟโฃฟโ Ÿโฃโก€โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €

โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃถโฃญโฃญโฃฟโกปโขฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโขโกถโข›โฃ‰โฃฅโขถโกฒโกนโกœโ กโ €โ €โ ˜โขฆโฃปโ ผโข€โฃฟโ Ÿโขโฃพโฃทโฃพโฃทโฃฝโกฟโ €โ ปโฃฟโฃฃโฃผโฃฟโกฟโ ‹โ €โ ˆโ โ โขฉโฃคโฃฌโฃญโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃทโฃ„โ €

โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ ธโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃœโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโก†โฃ™โ ›โ ‰โฃฉโกพโฃ‹โ ฐโฃฟโฃฝโกฟโ “โก‰โขฑโก™โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ ‰โ ƒโ Šโ ‰โ €โ ธโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโ ฟโ โ €โ €โข€โฃฉโฃคโฃ€โฃโ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ ฅโกโ ถโ พโขญโฃญโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโ Ÿ

โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ ˆโ ปโขฏโฃฟโฃฟโกฟโฃฟโ Ÿโ นโฃฟโฃ™โฃปโฃตโขŸโฃปโฃถโฃฟโกฎโ โขšโฃฐโฃˆโ ถโ ƒโ คโ „โ ‚โ €โ €โ €โ €โฃ€โฃ โฃพโฃฅโ ถโ ฏโ ™โ ‰โ โ €โ €โข€โกผโ ณโ ˆโฃฟโฃฏโกฟโ €โ  โฃ€โก€โก€โ ‘โ ขโขคโฃฌโฃโ ›โ ‹โ โ €โ €

โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โฃคโฃถโฃฟโฃฟโฃ›โฃŸโขฒโฃโกƒโ โ €โ €โ ˜โ ‹โข‰โฃ‰โฃโฃโ นโ Ÿโข€โฃ€โกŠโ ˆโฃกโฃคโฃžโ ปโขฟโฃฟโฃฆโฃคโก€โ ˆโ ‰โ ‰โ ‰โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โขฟโขกโ โก™โขฟโฃฟโ ‡โฃดโ ’โฃฟโฃฟโฃฌโฃ…โฃ€โ โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €

โ €โ €โ €โ €โฃฝโขธโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃ›โกปโขฟโฃ€โ €โ €โข โฃถโฃ›โฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโก†โ €โ ‰โ โ ˆโ “โ ฌโขญโฃ‹โฃŸโฃทโฃถโฃถโฃฟโฃ†โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ ˜โข†โขฉโ €โขผโกฟโขกโฃฟโ €โขนโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฆโ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €

โ €โ €โ €โ €โ นโฃ†โ ™โฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃถโฃพโฃฏโฃทโฃ„โขฏโฃฝโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃทโฃฆโ ˆโ ฒโก„โ ›โ ›โ ถโฃถโฃฌโฃญโฃ›โกปโขฟโฃฟโก†โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ ‘โ ƒโ €โ €โ ˆโขŸโก‡โขบโฃฟโฃฟโฃ›โฃปโฃฟโ ‡โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €

โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ ˆโ “โ บโ ฟโ ฟโ ›โก›โฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโกโฃฟโฃโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃคโ ฑโ Œโ ฃโ ˆโฃทโกขโฃโกปโขฟโฃฟโฃถโ Ÿโ โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ ‚โ ˆโ ›โฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโกŸโ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €

โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ ธโก“โ ผโขฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโฃŸโ ƒโ ˆโ ปโฃฟโ ŸโขปโฃฟโกŸโฃงโฃ…โ ’โ งโ €โ ˆโ ™โ ›โ ปโ †โ ‹โ โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ ˆโ ‚โ ˆโ ›โ ‹โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €

โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ ‰โ “โ ฆโ ‰โ โ ‰โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โข™โกƒโขฟโฃฟโฃทโฃดโฃถโ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €

โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ ˜โฃฟโฃฟโฃฟโ ‡โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €โ €

Sommie

Santilla

ยฉ SOMMIE SANTILLA 2026